Whamit!

The Weekly Newsletter of MIT Linguistics

LingLunch 11/19 - Iva Kovač (University of Vienna/MIT)

Speaker: Iva Kovač (University of Vienna/MIT)
Title: Spelling out the Bagel problem
Time: Thursday, November 19th, 12:30pm – 2pm
Location: 32-D461

Abstract: Croatian has two series of Negative Polarity Items (NPIs) that together give rise to the so-called Bagel problem (Pereltsvaig 2006): i-NPIs (e.g., itko ‘anybody’) are found in canonical NPI-licensing environments, except with local negation, where ni-NPIs (or Negative Concord Items; e.g., nitko ‘nobody’) appear instead. This talk focuses on the patterns that arise when ni- and i-NPIs are extracted from complement clauses of different sizes. The generalization that emerges is that movement within finite clauses may bleed Negative Concord, while movement across finite clauses does not (though it may feed Negative Concord). The distribution of i- and ni-NPIs is derived from an interplay of syntactic, semantic, and morphological factors: the two series of NPIs are treated as different surface realizations of the same underlying NPI (see also Uribe-Etxebarria 1996), which is subject to a semantic licensing requirement, and whose form is sensitive to c-command relations holding at spell-out. The more general conclusion reached is that a purely derivational operation such as Agree, if operative in Negative Concord (e.g., Zeijlstra 2004, 2022), cannot be the sole underlying factor.